Friday, July 11, 2008

Lesbian Couple Sues Blue Cross

Gay News From 365Gay.com

Lesbian Couple Sues Blue Cross
by 365Gay.com Newscenter Staff

Posted: July 10, 2008 - 3:00 pm ET

(Buffalo, New York) A Buffalo, New York lesbian couple is suing Blue Cross & Blue Shield accusing the insurer of contravening state policy in denying spousal benefits.

Jeanne Kornowicz and Joy Higgins were married in Ontario in 2006.

Kornowicz, a school psychologist for the Cheektowaga Central School district, applied to the school board to provide health coverage for Higgins, following a ruling in a similar case in Rochester where the court ruled that ruled New York State must recognize valid out-of-state marriages of lesbian and gay couples.

The school district approved but its insurer, Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Western New York, denied the coverage.

The couple is represented by the New York Civil Liberties Union.

In its court filing the ACLU noted the Rochester ruling which the state's highest court has upheld, and a directive issued last month by Gov. David Paterson instructing state agencies - including those governing insurance and health care - to immediately change policies and regulations to recognize gay marriages performed in areas where they are legal.

The ACLU also said that unlike Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Western New York, many other New York insurers, including other insurers carrying the Blue Cross & Blue Shield name, have been recognizing same-sex couples’ valid out-of-state marriages for years.

"As spouses and parents, Jeanne and Joy deserve the same protections that every other family in New York State enjoys," said Donna Lieberman, NYCLU executive director.

"Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Western New York must follow the laws of New York State and treat them as they do every other married couple."

Kornowicz and Higgins have had a committed relationship since 1998. In April 2006 the couple married in Ontario, Canada. Higgins gave birth to the couple’s daughter, Elizabeth Higgins, in July 2007, and Kornowicz’s second-parent adoption of Elizabeth was made final in January of this year.

"All we want is for our family to be treated fairly,” Kornowicz said. “It’s heartbreaking that we need to go to court so our family can find some security."

Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Western New York has not commented on the lawsuit.

Neither the Rochester ruling nor Paterson's directive allowed for same-sex couples to marry in New York. Both were limited to marriages performed only in California and Massachusetts and in countries such as Canada which have legalized gay marriage.

In 2006 the New York Court of Appeals, the state's highest court, ruled that same-sex couples do not have an automatic constitutional right to marry in the state. (story) It said that the issue, however, could be taken up by the Legislature.

Last year the Democratically-controlled New York State Assembly passed same-sex marriage legislation (story) but the GOP-controlled Senate has refused to take up the bill.

©365Gay.com 2008

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Calif. county refuses to ban gay marriage

Well this is a good thing. Stops any other counties from trying the same thing.

Calif. county refuses to ban gay marriage

Calif. county refuses to ban gay marriage

Tuesday, July 8, 2008


(07-08) 19:07 PDT Bakersfield, Calif. (AP) --

Kern County supervisors refused to ban gay marriage, rebutting a conservative group that sought to make it the first California county to reject the statewide policy.

The Campaign for Children and Families hoped the passage of a gay marriage ban in Kern County would embolden other counties to follow suit.

But supervisors declined to act on the measure after Bernard Barmann, the county's lawyer, said it would be illegal for the county to adopt its own same-sex marriage ban.

The Kern County clerk's office stopped offering all marriage ceremonies on June 15, the day before gay marriage became legal.

The five-member board also let die a motion to explore whether county employees who are willing to officiate same-sex weddings could be deputized for the duty by officials in neighboring San Bernardino County.

Townhall.com::Comparing McCain and Obama on Abortion and Same-Sex Marriage::By Janice Shaw Crouse

Townhall.com::Comparing McCain and Obama on Abortion and Same-Sex Marriage::By Janice Shaw Crouse


The old maxim “actions speak louder than words” is particularly appropriate in an election season. Count on it: Where there’s political rhetoric, there is spin. This year, as in the past couple of presidential elections, the Evangelical vote is a key voting bloc. That means political speeches that address abortion and same-sex “marriage” are important to decipher: Evangelicals’ perceptions relating to these issues may prove decisive in determining whom they vote for, if indeed they decide to vote at all.

What is essential for a true understanding of the candidates’ positions is to examine how each has backed his rhetoric with action. The best way to discern how the candidates will lead in the future is to lay out the salient facts about specific past behaviors — how they voted, what they did, the stances they took, and how they were rated on individual issues. Among family values issues important to Evangelicals, two that are particularly important are abortion and same-sex “marriage.”

Abortion: On the issue of abortion, the two major candidates are polar opposites. Senator McCain has said he would overturn Roe v. Wade, while Senator Obama has said he would “protect a woman’s right to choose” — the feminists’ language for abortion-on-demand. The highly influential political action group that works to expand access to abortion, NARAL (which is shorthand for NARAL Pro-Choice America), gave Senator McCain a zero percent rating for not supporting their cause and Senator Obama a 100 percent rating — confirming their very different voting records on issues related to abortion. McCain opposes partial-birth abortion, while Obama supports even that extreme version of abortion. McCain supports parental notification when a minor seeks an abortion; Obama opposes that parental right. Both candidates support research on embryonic stem cells and abortion in the case of rape. Senator McCain acknowledges the danger that abortion can pose for a woman’s health and has stated that the abortion issue reveals the kind of nation we are.

Same-Sex “Marriage”: The two candidates’ positions on same-sex “marriage” are not quite as diametrically opposed as are their stances on abortion issues. The Human Rights Campaign (the nation’s most radical activist group for Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender rights) rates McCain 33 percent and Obama 89 percent in their pro-homosexual rights record. Both candidates have said that they would leave the decision on same-sex “marriage” to the individual states, but McCain wobbles on the particulars. He has said that banning same-sex “marriage” is “unRepublican,” but he would support legislation that would prohibit same-sex “marriage.” McCain opposes hiring discrimination and would keep the military’s “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy because “it works.” He would be “comfortable with a gay president.” He would not, however, add “sexual orientation” to “hate crimes” legislation.

Obama, on the other hand, would add “sexual orientation” in the anti-discrimination laws. Further, he has said that homosexual behavior is no more immoral than heterosexual behavior. He believes that being “gay” or lesbian is inborn. He supports civil unions, opposes the California marriage initiative and the federal Defense of Marriage Act, and has stated that “gay rights are civil rights.” Obama thinks that having children exposed to homosexuality is fine because “they know already.”

Clearly, on the issue of abortion, Senator McCain is in closer harmony (except for embryonic stem cell research) with Evangelicals. On the issue of homosexual “rights,” Senator McCain is closer to Evangelicals, but there remain some thorny positions that will cause him difficulty in getting support from those he needs to win over before the November election if he hopes to win.

Monday, July 7, 2008

Debunking 10 Arguments Against Same-Sex Marriage

Arguments Against Same-Sex Marriage - Debunking 10 Arguments Against Same-Sex Marriage

10 Really Bad Arguments Against Same-Sex Marriage
Debunking the American Family Association's NoGayMarriage.com Platform
By Tom Head, About.com

Filed In:Equal Rights > Gender & Sexuality
The American Family Association, a right-wing advocacy group, has published a list of ten arguments against same-sex marriage. Ostensibly a summary of James Dobson's Marriage Under Fire, the arguments make a very loose case against same-sex marriage based almost entirely on slippery slopes and out-of-context quotations from the Good Book.

The inclination of many of my readers will be to get angry at the AFA. Please don't. They're actually doing the world a favor by putting these frequently whispered but seldom spoken arguments out in plain view, where they can be unpacked and dismantled.

Argument #1: That same-sex marriage would destroy the institution of marriage.
Point by point:
The Scandinavian studies to which the article presumably refers are the work of right-wing author Stanley Kurtz, who attempted to prove that same-sex marriage decreased the rate of heterosexual marriage in Denmark, Norway, and Sweden. This work has been discredited; see the last paragraph on this page for a summary explaining why.
The often-quoted reference from Romans 1:29-32 omits the following verse, Romans 2:1, which reads "Therefore you have no excuse, whoever you are, when you judge others; for in passing judgment on another you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, are doing the very same things."
No credible study has ever found that children are negatively impacted by being raised in a lesbian or gay household.



Argument #2: That if same-sex marriage is legalized, polygamy will follow.
Even if this concern had a rational basis, a simpler solution to this problem would be to propose a constitutional amendment banning polygamy--which would be easily ratified--rather than fooling around with an anti-gay constitutional amendment that only one-third of Americans support.Argument #3: That same-sex marriage would make heterosexual divorces too easy.
No, seriously. The article actually describes this as an "even greater objective of the homosexual movement" than the legalization of same-sex marriage proper. The article makes no real attempt to explain why this would happen, or how this would happen, but presumably one is expected to accept the statement at face value without giving any real thought to it.Argument #4: That same-sex marriage would require schools to teach tolerance.
People who support same-sex marriage also tend to support tolerance education in public schools, but the former isn't essential to the latter. Just ask Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, who vetoed a bill legalizing same-sex marriage and signed a bill enacting a gay-friendly public school tolerance curriculum in the same month.Argument #5: That same-sex married couples would be able to adopt.
Again, this does not require same-sex marriage. California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, New Jersey, New Mexico, and Oregon all specifically permit joint same-sex adoption, and most other states do not specifically prohibit it.Argument #6: That foster parents would be required to pass sensitivity training.
I'm not clear on what possible relationship this would have with same-sex marriage. Again, some states may require such training and some states may not, but the presence or absence of legalized same-sex marriage has nothing to do with the issue.Argument #7: That Social Security can't afford to pay for same-sex couples.
In argument #1, the AFA article criticized the low marriage rate. But in order for Social Security to be an issue, lesbian and gay Americans would have to remain single altogether rather than becoming heterosexual. The Religious Right's vision of millions of lesbians and gay Americans converting to heterosexuality and marrying members of the opposite sex would have to be written off entirely in order to produce any economic benefit based on denying same-sex couples the right to marry.

And any such benefit would be small-scale anyway. If 4% of the U.S. population identifies as lesbian or gay and half of lesbians and gay men get married, then that's only a 2% increase in the national marriage rate. That won't make or break Social Security.Argument #8: That legal U.S. same-sex marriage would encourage its spread.
This is the only argument on the list that doesn't strain credulity. Legal same-sex marriage in the United States probably would encourage other nations to also legalize same-sex marriage. But Canada was really ahead of the curve on this one, and will probably be given most of the credit by historians.Argument #9: That same-sex marriage would make evangelism more difficult.
And just what sort of evangelism are we talking about here, exactly?

In any event, I find it remarkable that any contemporary Christian would see a social policy they don't like as an obstacle to evangelism. A little less than two millennia ago, Christians were actually being executed by the Roman Empire, and surviving texts do not indicate that they saw this as an impediment to evangelism. Why would a change in marriage law, one that does not even directly impact heterosexual couples, somehow destroy evangelism when several generations of Roman emperors could not?Argument #10: That same-sex marriage would bring about divine retribution.
Again, a little perspective is in order. More than 3,000 children die every day of malaria; during the 1990s, an estimated 100 million children died of starvation; AIDS is sweeping the Global South; and the issue that will bring profound divine retribution is a change in marriage law?

I also have to question any theology that portrays God as some sort of violent, capricious bogeyman who must be supplicated, like the malevolent spirits of animist traditions, by sacrifices and incantations. The first generation of Christians welcomed the idea of divine intervention with the word "maranatha": "Come, Lord Jesus." There is no trace of that message, so central to the earliest Christian teachings, in this AFA article

Thursday, July 3, 2008

NJ congressman changes position on gay marriage -- Newsday.com

NJ congressman changes position on gay marriage -- Newsday.com


TRENTON, N.J. - Congressman Steve Rothman says a member of his own family persuaded him to change his position on same-sex marriage.

The Bergen County Democrat says he now supports gay and lesbian couples' right to marry, and has become a member of the House Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender Caucus.

Rothman said his 19-year-old stepdaughter, who is a lesbian, convinced him that same-sex couples deserve the right to marry.

Speaking on Sirius Satellite Radio's OutQ program Tuesday afternoon, the 55-year-old congressman said he has long supported civil unions but now backs gay marriage because old arguments against same-sex unions no longer work.

news: Same-sex Wisconsin couples willing to risk criminal penalties to marry in California

news: Same-sex Wisconsin couples willing to risk criminal penalties to marry in California

Jane Burns
July 1, 2008

Every summer, Bob Klebba and David Waugh take a family beach vacation to San Diego. Besides fun and sun, this year's trip will have a little something extra: a wedding.

The two Madison men will be getting married at a San Diego courthouse in August. In May, the California Supreme Court ruled that barring same-sex couples from marriage is unconstitutional. Since June 17, same-sex couples have been getting married throughout California. Non-residents are allowed to marry there, too.

"What we might be looking for is outside recognition of our relationship -- recognition from society," Klebba said. "This is a way to ask for that recognition. Happily, California is willing to give us that."

Wisconsin, however, is not. Not only will Klebba's and Waugh's marriage not be recognized here, they could be taking a legal risk by entering into it. Wisconsin is a state that imposes criminal penalties on residents if they enter a marriage outside the state that would be prohibited in the state. The law was created to prohibit underage couples from crossing state lines to marry, but it could be interpreted to apply to same-sex marriages, according to Glenn Carlson of Fair Wisconsin, an advocacy group for gays and lesbians. In Wisconsin, the penalty is a fine of up to $10,000, nine months in prison, or both.

"It would be interesting to be prosecuted," Klebba said. "It would really bring up a reaction in the public sentiment."

That's not why Klebba and Waugh are getting married, however. They're doing it because of what it means to each other.

"I want to have the same opportunity as everybody else to let my partner know, in the strongest of ways, that I am committed to him for life," Waugh said. "Marriage is kind of the ultimate, top-level commitment you can make with another person."

That's why Madisonians Kathy Cox and Kim Whalen also will be traveling to California in August. Last month, the west side couple celebrated 20 years together.

"It's the final piece of the puzzle," Cox said. "It legitimizes how we've been living our lives."

IN 2006, Wisconsin voters approved a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage. Carlson, who is executive director of Fair Wisconsin, said his group's next political challenge is working to get partnership recognition through in the next legislative session.

Carlson said he hadn't heard of many couples heading to California. He didn't know if that was because it won't be recognized here in Wisconsin, the legal risks or simply because of the costs of traveling to California.

"Some people will go, and I think it's great," he said. "I haven't heard of anyone who wants to use this as a way to challenge the courts. That message seems to be getting out: Please don't make a federal case of this."

Lambda Legal, a civil rights organization that focuses on gay rights, has issued an advisory called "Make Change, Not Lawsuits." It urges same-sex couples to let the issue work out state by state instead of risking a setback with a lawsuit at the federal level or in their home state.

CLICK LINK FOR FULL STORY

Obama opposes California same-sex marriage ban, which McCain supports

Obama opposes California same-sex marriage ban, which McCain supports


John Wildermuth, Chronicle Staff Writer

Wednesday, July 2, 2008


(07-01) 12:47 PDT SAN FRANCISCO -- Democratic Sen. Barack Obama has announced his opposition to a November ballot measure that would ban same-sex marriage in California, a move that puts gay rights front and center in the 2008 presidential campaign.

In a letter to San Francisco's Alice B. Toklas Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transgender Democratic Club Sunday, the presumptive presidential nominee said he opposed "the divisive and discriminatory efforts to amend the California Constitution" and similar efforts in other states.

Earlier last week, Arizona Republican Sen. John McCain, the GOP standard-bearer in November, took the other side. He told officials of Protect Marriage, a coalition that gathered 1.1 million signatures for the California measure, that he backed their efforts "to recognize marriage as a unique institution between a man and a woman."

Obama is skating gingerly past his previous position on the issue. The Illinois senator has said repeatedly that he believes marriage should only be between man and a woman. When the California Supreme Court overturned the state's ban on same-sex marriage in May, Obama released a carefully nuanced statement saying he respected the court's decision, believed states should make their own decisions on marriage and "will continue to fight for civil unions as President."

But civil unions, gay activists have often argued, aren't the same as marriage, which would put Obama on the wrong side of what's increasingly seen as a civil rights issue.

Obama's opposition to the same-sex marriage ban, however, brought immediate praise from groups trying to defeat Prop. 8 in California, which would amend the state constitution to say that "only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California."

"It's great to see Senator Obama's statement, which is consistent with what he has said in the past about allowing each state to make its own decision," said Geoff Kors, executive director of Equality for All, which is heading the Prop. 8 opposition. "Is it ideal that he doesn't support same-sex marriage? No. But it's important when political leaders say gay and lesbian couples should be treated equally."

It's no surprise to see McCain on the side of the same-sex marriage ban. While he opposed a GOP-backed 2004 federal constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage, he supported a failed 2006 Arizona initiative that would have blocked not only same-sex marriages, but also domestic partnerships.

For both campaigns, the decision to get involved in the same-sex marriage debate carries plenty of political risks. California is one of three states with same-sex marriage bans on the November ballot. While California is seen as Obama country and Arizona is McCain's home state, Florida, the third state seeking to limit marriage to a man and a woman, is a tossup state that will be a major prize in the November election.

E-mail John Wildermuth at jwildermuth@sfchronicle.com