Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Box Turtle Bulletin » Marriage update – around the states

Box Turtle Bulletin » Marriage update – around the states: "- Sent using Google Toolbar"


Timothy Kincaid
November 29th, 2010

The 2010 election has changed the dynamic in a few states and presents both opportunities and challenges for supporters of marriage equality. Here are how I see the current landscape:

Hawaii – Neil Abercrombie, the newly elected governor of Hawaii, is a strong advocate for civil unions. Earlier this year the legislature overwhelmingly approved a civil unions bill and such a bill is likely to be presented again.

Illinois – it is expected that the state legislature will vote this week on a civil unions bill during a lame-duck session. There is adequate support in the Senate, but the House vote is uncertain. Should it pass, Governor Pat Quinn, a strong supporter who was just reelected, will sign the bill. This bill seems to be taking on the impression of a Catholic v. Protestant fight, with NOM and the Catholic Bishop serving as the public face in opposition to civil unions, while a great many Protestants ministers have endorsed the bill.

Minnesota – Mark Dayton holds a lead in the governor’s election over anti-gay Tom Emmer, but the election will not be determined until a recount is completed. Republicans took control of both houses of legislature, so no pro-equality bills are expected; but if Dayton is confirmed there also will be no anti-equality bills either.

The one concern might be that Republicans could try and put a constitutional amendment on the 2012 ballot that bans both marriage and civil unions. While that may seem like a great idea to anti-gay activists, Emmer ran a homophobic campaign designed to appeal to those who oppose marriage equality and it does not appear to have been successful. I think it likely that an anti-marriage amendment would pass, but anti-civil unions may be too much, and it is becoming increasingly more risky for anti-gays to make such assumptions. Additionally, attitudes can change dramatically in the next two years.

Meanwhile, three couples are suing the state claiming that laws restricting marriage to opposite-sex couples violate the state constitution. Today, a judge rejected the request of the Minnesota Family Counsel to intervene:

“The Council’s alleged injuries would occur solely due to its sincerely-held belief that principles rooted in its interpretations of religious texts are best for the well-being of children and families, and that marriage only between one man and one woman accords with these principles,” wrote Minnesota Fourth District Court Judge Mary S. DuFrense (PDF). “The Court certainly understands that the Council feels strongly about the social issue of same-sex marriage. Strong feelings, however, do not establish a legal interest in a lawsuit.”

Iowa – after three Supreme Court Justices were denied confirmation, anti-gay activists were celebrating. But as the Senate majority leader has committed to blocking any changes to the Iowa constitution, it is unlikely that marriage will be reversed.

New Hampshire – NOM is crowing that anti-marriage activists have taken over both houses. However, my analysis suggests that any reversal of marriage equality is unlikely. While Republicans took a veto-proof majority, a significant number have already voted against any repeal of the law.

Maine – Republican Paul LePage was elected governor, effectively eliminating any forward movement on marriage equality. However LePage supports the current domestic partnership laws so things will remain status quo for a while.

New York – this one is a big question mark. Incoming Governor Cuomo has promised to get marriage legalized. And after the last vote, state legislators have discovered that “things as they are” may well be the most dangerous position to hold; gay activists refused to play the “any Democrat is better than a Republican” game and set their sites on defeating anti-marriage votes.

Going by last year’s vote count, the current best case scenario is that we are three votes shy of what we need (there are still some undecided elections). However, this time our side is taking to the airwaves to drum up public support, and polls show that New Yorkers support marriage equality. What was a party-line vote last year may well be viewed this year in terms of tolerance and New York values and there may be an entirely different dynamic.

Rhode Island – Former-Republican Lincoln Chaffee, who ran as an Independent, beat both the Democrat and the Republican candidates to take governor of the tiny state. And one of his first actions was to inform NOM that their opinion on marriage was not of any value to him. Rhode Islanders support marriage equality, and with Chaffee’s backing there is a good chance that RI will be the next marriage state.

Maryland – another contender for next marriage state, Maryland did not suffer party reversal. A plurality of voter support marriage equality, and gay State Sen. Richard Madaleno is guardedly optimistic that marriage will be voted in, perhaps as early as January.

His optimism stems from a number of developments on Election Day 2010, some of which ran absolutely counter to national trends. In the Maryland Senate, Democrats actually expanded their majority to a 35-12 advantage over Republicans. And some Democrats who lost their seats did so in primary fights with more progressive challengers, many of whom vowed to be even stronger champions for marriage equality.

And, of course, all of the above could be impacted by Perry v. Schwarzenegger should the courts find that marriage laws which restrict gay people from participation are contrary to the Due Process or Equal Protections clauses of the 14th Amendement

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello I’m new here. I’m sorry if thisis not the right place for this
post but I was hopingsome one here on samesexmarriageadvocate.blogspot.com would be able to assist me. Happy to be here.

Anonymous said...

My inquires are: Simply how much can a company legally charge you to let a policy holder out of his auto insurance?
Exactly how much does your company cost when someone wishes to cancel and how much pressure can you use to keep them?
What are some ideas something like that we can say if our consumer has many months still left on his existing motor vehicle policy? Surely, we are not going to wait until his renewal comes due each and every time.

Anonymous said...

Pennsylvania has minimal requirements on coverage, you need to compare these minimum requirements with the PA auto insurance quote offered by 3 auto insurer at least. Secondly, you need to consider the location. It’s not just about convenience. The insurance agents are very much likely to be thoroughly familiarized with the state law of Pennsylvania if they’re local. And third comes, research reputation. Try to observe how quickly or seamlessly your chosen PA auto insurance company can responds when it’s needed.I have this info and need to know if this coorect or find more some where else. Any help??

Anonymous said...

hid car lights authorized dealers car upolstery repair auto zone meridian oxygen mini vaporizer clip art car crash

Anonymous said...

gill bradley car hire full car service price custom ford mustang part 360 auto grand theft hire smart corporation new jersey

rick said...

Hi,

I am looking for a VPS solutions. Who is the best provider in your eyes of VPS hosting?

-Rick

Anonymous said...

Solely choice some insurance company which provides substantial debt balance, okay better-known plus decidedly respected by simply folks. You can actually definitely find that a particular for your specific geographic area

Anonymous said...

THE CUTEST TEEN GIRL IN THE WORLD DOING THINGS SHE KNOWS SHE SHOULDN’T ONLY
ADORABLE BLONDE TEEN SWEETIE AND HER FRIENDS HAVING FUN TOGETHER AND WITH VERY LUCKY GUYS.
OUR MOST POPULAR TEEN GIRL HAS HER VERY OWN SITE AND SHE IS BEING NAUGHTY
SHE LOOKS INNOCENT… LOOKS CAN BE VERY DECEIVING…
THESE CUTE TEEN GIRLS HAVE FOUND A PLACE TO BEHAVE BAD AND LOLLY RUNS THE SHOW OVER
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU GET A VERY CUTE AND HORNY TEEN GIRL AND GIVE HER A WEBSITE TO PLAY WITH.
LOLLY INVITES YOU INTO THE WORLD OF A CUTE TEEN GIRL THAT LOOKS SWEET AND INNOCENT BUT IS REALLY HORNY AS HELL. SHE SUCKS, FUCKS, DOES OTHER GIRLS AND PUTS THINGS IN HER PUSSY AND IT’S ONLY

Anonymous said...

56465.....36640

Anonymous said...

http://choroby-psychiczne.eu